<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1583050835334800&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">
Steidl & Steinberg
Menu
Close
  • Why Steidl & Steinberg
  • Areas of Practice
    • Overview
    • Personal Bankruptcy
    • Business Bankruptcy
    • Taxes
    • Assessment Appeals
  • Our Attorneys
    • Meet Our Attorneys
    • Ken Steidl
    • Kenny Steinberg
    • Julie Steidl
    • Christopher Frye
    • Lauren Lamb
    • Abagale Steidl
    • Brian Dodson
    • Nathan Chase
  • Our Locations
    • Steidl & Steinberg Offices
    • Beaver
    • Belle Vernon
    • Butler/Cranberry
    • Carnegie
    • Erie
    • Greensburg
    • Hermitage
    • Meadville
    • Monroeville
    • New Kensington
    • Pittsburgh
    • Uniontown
    • Washington
  • Blog
  • Reviews

Schedule Your Free Consultation

Contact Us
  • Toll Free: 800-360-9392
  • Pittsburgh: 412-391-8000
  • Erie: 814-451-1131
  • Why Steidl & Steinberg
  • Areas of Practice
    • Overview
    • Personal Bankruptcy
    • Business Bankruptcy
    • Taxes
    • Assessment Appeals
  • Our Attorneys
    • Meet Our Attorneys
    • Ken Steidl
    • Kenny Steinberg
    • Julie Steidl
    • Christopher Frye
    • Lauren Lamb
    • Abagale Steidl
    • Brian Dodson
    • Nathan Chase
  • Our Locations
    • Steidl & Steinberg Offices
    • Beaver
    • Belle Vernon
    • Butler/Cranberry
    • Carnegie
    • Erie
    • Greensburg
    • Hermitage
    • Meadville
    • Monroeville
    • New Kensington
    • Pittsburgh
    • Uniontown
    • Washington
  • Blog
  • Reviews
Blog

Topics

  • Bankruptcy (239)
  • bankruptcy (221)
  • Steidl and Steinberg (220)
  • Money Matters (211)
  • pittsburgh (203)
  • Allegheny County (198)
  • Washington County (191)
  • debt (189)
  • Credit Card Debt (187)
  • Local News (184)
  • Monroeville (184)
  • Beaver (183)
  • Erie (183)
  • financial concerns (182)
  • Beaver County (181)
  • New Kensington (179)
  • Greensburg (178)
  • budget (178)
  • creditors (178)
  • Taxes (177)
  • Washington (177)
  • Belle Vernon (176)
  • Lawrence County (174)
  • Loans and Mortgages (174)
  • budgeting (174)
  • credit (174)
  • Butler County (173)
  • bankruptcy sale (170)
  • Chapter 13 (166)
  • Chapter 7 (166)
  • Erie County (166)
  • Hermitage (164)
  • Chapter 11 (160)
  • foreclosure (160)
  • pittsburgh finance (158)
  • credit card act (157)
  • Foreclosure (155)
  • attorney (153)
  • co-sign loans (152)
  • mortgage (146)
  • Repossession (144)
  • Greene County (143)
  • taxes (143)
  • Butler (142)
  • student loans (142)
  • Mercer County (140)
  • Fayette County (138)
  • Student loans (135)
  • economic recovery (135)
  • Westmoreland County (134)
  • refinance (133)
  • real estate taxes (128)
  • modification (126)
  • job layoff (119)
  • law firm (113)
  • Meadville (110)
  • Mercer (96)
  • Irwin (91)
  • Latrobe (90)
  • mortgage modification (89)
  • Uniontown (77)
  • New Castle (76)
  • Waynesburg (70)
  • Canonsburg (63)
  • Venango County (54)
  • Property Tax Assessment (51)
  • Ligonier (43)
  • Cranberry Township (41)
  • Uncategorized (28)
  • Franklin (24)
  • Grove City (24)
  • Murrysville (24)
  • Oil City (22)
  • banktuptcy (21)
  • Crawford County (20)
  • debt relief (19)
  • credit card debt (17)
  • chapter 7 (16)
  • Connellsville (15)
  • McKeesport (15)
  • assessment (15)
  • Chapter 13 bankruptcy (12)
  • Sharon (12)
  • debt settlement (12)
  • Chapter 7 bankruptcy (11)
  • Warren County (11)
  • truth in bankruptcy (10)
  • Chapter 11 bankruptcy (9)
  • Steidl & Steinberg (9)
  • Cranberry (8)
  • Warren (8)
  • debt consolidation (8)
  • IRS (7)
  • bankruptcy myths (7)
  • property assessment (7)
  • Conneaut Lake (6)
  • Conneaut Lake Park (6)
  • Social Security benefits (6)
  • appraisal (6)
  • bankruptcy court (6)
  • credit card (6)
  • credit cards (6)
  • free bankruptcy consultation (6)
  • assessment appeal (5)
  • bankruptcy attorney (5)
  • credit score (5)
  • debt collection (5)
  • pittsburgh jobs (5)
  • reassessment (5)
  • tax attorney (5)
  • Ambridge (4)
  • Armstrong County (4)
  • bankruptcy consultation (4)
  • bankruptcy filing (4)
  • bills (4)
  • debt collectors (4)
  • debt settlement companies (4)
  • legal consultation (4)
  • property taxes (4)
  • reasons to file bankruptcy (4)
  • student loan (4)
  • Aliquippa (3)
  • Beaver Falls (3)
  • Blairsville (3)
  • Clarion County (3)
  • Cranberry Twp. (3)
  • Franklin County (3)
  • Indiana (3)
  • Penn Hills (3)
  • bankruptcy attorney fees (3)
  • consumer debt (3)
  • debt free (3)
  • debt problems (3)
  • divorce (3)
  • family debt (3)
  • formal hearings (3)
  • free consultation (3)
  • loan modification (3)
  • property reassessment (3)
  • repossession (3)
  • repossession of a car (3)
  • seniors (3)
  • student loan debt (3)
  • 401k (2)
  • Bentleyville (2)
  • Board of Viewers (2)
  • Clarion (2)
  • Conneaut (2)
  • Coraopolis (2)
  • Freedom (2)
  • Girard (2)
  • Greenville (2)
  • Jamestown (2)
  • Johnstown (2)
  • Kittanning (2)
  • Linesville (2)
  • McMurray (2)
  • Midland (2)
  • Mon Valley (2)
  • Monaca (2)
  • Monongahela (2)
  • Moon (2)
  • Obamacare (2)
  • Radio Shack (2)
  • Sewickley (2)
  • Shippensburg (2)
  • West Mifflin (2)
  • Wexford (2)
  • amusement park (2)
  • bankruptcy and marriage (2)
  • bankruptcy and your spouse (2)
  • bankruptcy discharge (2)
  • bankruptcy exemptions (2)
  • bankruptcy fear (2)
  • bankruptcy fees (2)
  • commercial (2)
  • credit scores (2)
  • creditor (2)
  • debt negotiation (2)
  • default (2)
  • exemptions (2)
  • finance (2)
  • formal appeal (2)
  • fresh start (2)
  • health insurance (2)
  • income tax (2)
  • income tax refund (2)
  • law suit (2)
  • lawsuits (2)
  • loan payments (2)
  • loss mitigation (2)
  • mortgage payments (2)
  • multiple bankruptcies (2)
  • multiple bankruptcy filings (2)
  • pay the bills (2)
  • pay your bills (2)
  • pension (2)
  • property assessment appeal (2)
  • property tax appeal (2)
  • property tax reassessment (2)
  • repossession of a car in bankruptcy (2)
  • residential (2)
  • retirement fund (2)
  • sheriff sale (2)
  • social security (2)
  • sued (2)
  • tax (2)
  • tax preparation (2)
  • tax services (2)
  • unemployment (2)
  • utility bill (2)
  • ATI lockout (1)
  • Adams County (1)
  • Affordable Care Act (1)
  • Bethel Park (1)
  • Blue Streak (1)
  • Bridgeville (1)
  • Burgettstown (1)
  • Chapter 9 (1)
  • Charleroi (1)
  • Clairton (1)
  • Conneaut Lake bankruptcy (1)
  • Dormont (1)
  • Edinboro (1)
  • Erie Otters (1)
  • Finland (1)
  • Fox Chapel (1)
  • Freeport (1)
  • Frsanklin (1)
  • Hampton (1)
  • Harmar (1)
  • IRA (1)
  • Internal Revenue Service (1)
  • Jack Johnson (1)
  • Jackson Township (1)
  • Judge Thomas Agresti (1)
  • LIHEAP (1)
  • McDonald (1)
  • Mt. Lebanon (1)
  • Mt. Pleasant (1)
  • Natrona Heights (1)
  • New Brighton (1)
  • NewCastle (1)
  • North East (1)
  • OHL (1)
  • Oreck (1)
  • Peters Township (1)
  • Presque Isle (1)
  • Rochester (1)
  • Santa Claus (1)
  • Santa Claus Village (1)
  • Sherry Bassin (1)
  • Slippery Rock (1)
  • Southpointe (1)
  • Sprint (1)
  • Steidl & Steinberg Tax Services (1)
  • Supreme Court (1)
  • Surrender your house (1)
  • Taxpayer Bill of Rights (1)
  • Tyler Technology (1)
  • United States Supreme Court (1)
  • Vanport (1)
  • Venango (1)
  • Venanon County (1)
  • Venetia (1)
  • Washington assessment (1)
  • Waynesburgv (1)
  • Zillow (1)
  • appraiser (1)
  • attach wages (1)
  • attorney fees (1)
  • balance transfer (1)
  • bank account (1)
  • bankruptcy judge (1)
  • bankruptcy petition (1)
  • bankruptcy scam (1)
  • being sued (1)
  • borrowers (1)
  • business debt (1)
  • car loans (1)
  • cell phones (1)
  • co-signing loans (1)
  • co-signing student loans (1)
  • credit card balance transfer (1)
  • credit line (1)
  • deficiency balance (1)
  • disability (1)
  • discharge (1)
  • don't pay your bills (1)
  • e-mails (1)
  • embarrassed (1)
  • extension to file taxes (1)
  • fees (1)
  • finances (1)
  • fixed income (1)
  • form 501C (1)
  • fraudulent transfer (1)
  • garnish wages (1)
  • gift cards (1)
  • give up house (1)
  • giving thanks (1)
  • health care (1)
  • heating assistance (1)
  • income tax return (1)
  • income taxes (1)
  • insurance (1)
  • interest rates (1)
  • job growth (1)
  • judgments (1)
  • lawsuit (1)
  • letter 501C (1)
  • loss of income (1)
  • medical bills (1)
  • mortgage arrears (1)
  • mortgage foreclosure (1)
  • mortgage loan modification (1)
  • moving (1)
  • multiple filings (1)
  • pedestrian bridge (1)
  • personal income taxes (1)
  • personal information (1)
  • phishing (1)
  • preferential payments (1)
  • prom (1)
  • real estate tax (1)
  • real estate tax appeal (1)
  • residential appraiser (1)
  • retired (1)
  • retirement (1)
  • scam (1)
  • scams (1)
  • school tax (1)
  • separation (1)
  • shared responsibility payment (1)
  • small business (1)
  • so-sign student loan (1)
  • spouse (1)
  • student loan default (1)
  • suit (1)
  • tax amnesty (1)
  • tax deductions (1)
  • tax delinquincy (1)
  • tax payer rights (1)
  • tax preparer (1)
  • tax professional (1)
  • tax questions (1)
  • tax refund (1)
  • tax return (1)
  • thankful (1)
  • time limit debt collection (1)
  • transfer property (1)
  • under the table (1)
  • utility bills (1)
  • voluntary repossession (1)
  • working under the table (1)
see all
    Steidl & Steinberg PC BBB Business Review

    Wrong case for student loan court appeal

    Posted on January 14, 2016 by Chris Frye

    The United States Supreme Court recently denied hearing an appeal of a Wisconsin man who was trying to eliminate more than $260,000.00 in student loans in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy proceeding. With student loan debt at an all-time high, and defaults on paying those student loans at an all-time high, the issue of eliminating student loans in bankruptcy is ripe for a Supreme Court decision. Especially because the standard being used by most courts to determine whether a student loan can be discharged is decades old and is extremely stringent.

    So, why did the Supreme Court deny hearing this appeal? It most likely will never be totally clear. However, this may not be the case that individuals with student loan debt would have wanted in front of the Supreme Court.

    As stated above, it is extremely difficult to eliminate student loans in a bankruptcy based on the current standard used by most courts in the country. Any relaxation of this standard would be welcome by many of the student loan borrowers who can’t make their payments despite their best effort. However, the individual who brought the appeal in this instance claimed that “his alcoholism, depression and criminal record have prevented him from finding a job and repaying his debt “. He also reportedly failed the bar exam twice after attending law school.

    Is this the case that borrowers would like for the Supreme Court to decide and set a new standard with? In my opinion, it is not. As unfortunate as it is that this individual apparently had alcohol problems and some run-ins with the law leading to a criminal record, what the Supreme Court really needs to decide on appeal is a case in which a good faith effort was made to repay the debt by someone without these issues. In other words, an individual who couldn’t use such extreme extenuating factors as a reason for not being able to pay the loans.  Only then would there most likely be any real change in the standard to eliminate student loan debt for those in need.

    To be clear, the time seems to be right for the standard for getting relief from student loans in a bankruptcy to be modified and made less stringent. However, given the circumstances, this case didn’t seem to be the right set of circumstances for the Court to set a new standard. Here’s hoping that a case with the right circumstances comes along soon.

    Did you find value in this post? Share This!

    • Tweet

    This entry was posted in bankruptcy sale, Chapter 11, Chapter 13, credit, credit card act, creditors, debt, Hermitage, Irwin, Allegheny County, attorney, bankruptcy, Bankruptcy, Beaver, Beaver County, Belle Vernon, budget, budgeting, Butler, Butler County, Chapter 7, co-sign loans, Credit Card Debt, economic recovery, Erie, Erie County, Fayette County, financial concerns, foreclosure, Foreclosure, Greene County, Greensburg, Latrobe, law firm, Lawrence County, Loans and Mortgages, Local News, Meadville, Mercer, Mercer County, modification, Money Matters, Monroeville, mortgage, mortgage modification, New Castle, New Kensington, pittsburgh, pittsburgh finance, Repossession, Steidl and Steinberg, student loan, student loans, Student loans, Supreme Court, Taxes, taxes, Uniontown, United States Supreme Court, Venango County, Washington, Washington County, Waynesburg, Westmoreland County

    Contact Us Toll Free: 1-800-360-9392

    Southwestern PA Main Office - Pittsburgh - 412-391-8000

    Northwestern PA Main Office - Erie - 814-451-1131

    Follow Us

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • YouTube

    The Law Offices of Steidl & Steinberg | 28th Floor, Gulf Tower | Pittsburgh, PA 15219 USA

    Copyright © 2020 Steidl & Steinberg.

    Website by Imagebox